Here are some results of a round robin match with time control 1 minute + 2 second increment, same book, reversed colors, 512 mb hash, pb off.
Rybka3x64(8cpus+tbs) 15/24
IvanHoev81x64(4cpus) 15/24
Igorrit0086v8x64(8cpus) 14/24
IvanHoe1x64(4cpus) 13.5/24
DeepShredder12x64(8cpus+tbs) 2.5/24
It seems IvanHoev81x64 is the strongest engine here, but many more games would need to be run to confirm this. IvanHoev81 was using only 4 cpus and scored the same as Rybka3 with 8 cpus. Anyway, I see some newer releases have come....